Nicole Nicolay

Nicole Nicolay

/ / patient. warmhearted. reliable.

Renowned for her unwavering commitment to providing exceptional service and helping clients achieve their homeownership dreams, Nicole Nicolay has earned a spot amongst Denver’s luxury real estate professionals. Her passion for delivering seamless and extraordinary experiences is the basis of Nicole’s client-centric approach, and her meticulous attention to detail ensures a stress-free and unforgettable journey.

Nicole’s expertise is rooted in her impressive educational background, having earned her undergraduate degree from the prestigious CU Boulder Leeds School of Business with an emphasis in Real Estate. Prior to graduating, Nicole worked as a licensed assistant and began building a wealth of knowledge in the many facets of real estate, including title, lending, real estate law, finance, accounting and investing. Although she has been drawn to real estate from a young age, Nicole chose her career because of her love of interacting with and helping others — and given her status as a 5-Star Professional and First-Time Homebuyer Specialist, Nicole chose the right path for both herself and her clients.

Beyond her remarkable professional achievements, Nicole is dedicated to making a positive impact in her community. Nicole’s clients consistently commend her serene approach throughout the real estate process, appreciating her meticulous attention to detail. Nicole’s recent home purchase in Platte Park (and the extensive renovations that followed) has honed her experience in revitalizing historic architecture for the modern homeowner. With her experience managing rental and investment properties, Nicole enjoys educating her clients on the intricacies of investment opportunities and how to build a robust real estate portfolio.

the lauren jensen group within milehimodern

Equipped with an east coast drive and flawless synergy, Lauren Jensen and Nicole Nicolay share a passion for helping their clients achieve their real estate goals. The Colorado University graduates place a profound emphasis on collaboration and communication in their strategy, allowing their partnership to feel naturally effortless from the beginning. The duo even utilizes a similar tone in negotiations and emails. Lauren and Nicole’s approach is based on a customized experience for their clients while maintaining a solid foundation of transparency, tireless effort and above all, trust. Both Lauren and Nicole are instinctively drawn to helping others — a shared characteristic that makes their clients feel like they are working with close friends.

professional proficiencies

  • Denver neighborhood expert
  • 5-Star Professional Award-Winner
  • First-Time Homebuyer Specialist

Nicole takes any opportunity she can to spend time outdoors, especially with her friends, family and soon-to-be husband, Erik. She never skips a daily walk in Washington Park and frequently visits Old South Pearl Street Farmers Market. Aside from spending time outdoors and being with her friends and family, Nicole also enjoys Pilates classes at Lagree Luxe in Cherry Creek and generally supporting local businesses in her neighborhood.

home staples

  • Breville espresso maker
  • comfy slippers
  • plants — lots of them

personal passions

let’s connect

get in touch

client love

Nicole utilized the perfect amount of communication for me from the beginning; she wasn’t pushy and quickly learned my preferred style of communication (via text, and call when necessary, with extremely prompt replies) and desires in a home, so much so that she could foresee what properties I’d be interested in at the exact time I was looking at them online. In my case, I more or less knew the types of properties I was interested in and checked listings frequently, and Nicole used the perfect combination of occasional suggestions and super quick responsiveness to my proactive requests to see properties. Her follow-up with listing agents was exceptionally quick and helpful, as well- I never felt like I was waiting on her for anything; it felt like we were a true team working seamlessly together throughout the entire process!
Sarah HMay 16, 2024
Nicole has a needed calming force throughout this entire process. Big decisions always make me very nervous and Nicole was always calm, steady, forthright, and reassuring. We wanted to move fast following our decision to sell, and Nicole moved very quickly and made it all happen. She did everything we asked during the negotiation. We definitely feel our best interests were served well. I plan to recommend Nicole to anyone I know thinking of buying or selling.
James HMay 16, 2024
Nicole was INCREDIBLE. By every definition of the word. As a first time homebuyer, I needed help with literally everything. I was uneducated about the process, area, and basically starting from complete scratch. From day one, Nicole helped me get in contact with the right stakeholders, asked me the right questions that allowed me to better understand what I even wanted. She worked with me for multiple months to get the showings we wanted and always took my feedback to adjust her future recommendations. She couldn’t have been more responsive or helpful to guiding my process and would absolutely recommend her services to anyone and everyone. Truly find it hard to believe you could find anyone that would have provided more value in this process than Nicole.
Jack SMay 16, 2024
Nicole exceeded our expectations on every level. Her expertise of the Denver real estate market and impeccable negotiation skills made the sale of our home and transition to our new place seamless. Nicole’s every action throughout our selling journey demonstrated an unwavering fiduciary commitment, and we look forward to working with her again in the future.
George NMay 16, 2024
Pure excellence! Nicole is extremely hardworking, professional, knowledgable, and so friendly. I never had a doubt in my mind throughout the entire process that I wasn’t in good hands. She was on top of everything and kept me updated constantly which reassured me she is doing her best to sell my home and she did just that. So thankful for her and her team and will 100% utilize her again on my next purchase. I can’t imagine a better experience than the one I had. Hire her!
Erin KMay 16, 2024
Nicole is a top-notch agent. From our first conversation, she was attentive, found exactly what I was looking for, and answered any and all questions along the way. Our negotiation and close were butter smooth and I couldn’t be happier with the entire experience. I’ll definitely recommend her to anyone looking for a home in the Denver area!
Craig NMay 16, 2024
I can’t put into word how amazing my experience was with Nicole! She by far exceeded all my expectations. You can see she truly enjoys her job and helping her clients find a perfect home for them. I mostly appreciated her honesty with properties or areas she didn’t see fit for me. She is a fantastic communicator and makes sure you’re comfortable and informed along every step. I would 100 % suggested Nicole for anyone searching for a home. Also.. she’s the sweetest!!
Chelsea DMay 16, 2024
Being a first time homebuyer in a new state can easily make anyone anxious about the process. After purchasing my first home through Nicole, I can easily testify that this was not the case at all. Nicole made the entire process smooth, easy and overall, incredible. From the moment we first met her to discuss what we were looking for, she brought a friendly personality that anyone could easily relate to while still applying incredible knowledge to ensure we made a good long term investment in our future. We could easily go on with how many great things we can say about Nicole and our experience buying our first home, and truly feel that anyone who decides to work with her on their home buying experience will express the same appreciation that we did. If there were more stars to give, I would! Don’t pass up on an incredible opportunity to work with Nicole on your home buying experience.
Austin FMay 16, 2024

my listings

my sales